Page 38 - 175 Varsity ebook
P. 38

36 /                                                                                                                                                                                                                   / 37


                                                                                                                          scared  of  losing  my  ability  to  think  means I’m not really learning English,  learning and future development op-
                                                                                                                          critically,” the architecture major stu-  processing information and forming  portunities,” he says.
                                                                                                                          dent says.                         the structure of a piece of writing my-
                                                                                                                             Liu has integrated GenAI into his  self,” he explains.
              University students find GenAI useful for getting better grades                                             study after taking a digital literacy

           and efficiency but not for learning.                                                                           course which taught students how to
                                                                                                                          use AI responsibly.
                                                                                                                             “For my essay on the middle class
                                                                                                                          and poverty in China, I used GenAI to
                                                                                                                          scout sources and analyse the assigned
                                                                                                                          article. It gave me ideas and helped me
                                                                                                                          highlight key points. I ended up earn-
                                                                                                                          ing A- for that assignment,” he says.
                                                                                                                             “I feel guilty sometimes, however.
                                                                                                                          I do half of the thinking, and AI does
                                                                                                                          the rest. But it still feels like my learn-
              GenAI Makes Me Feel Stupid                                                                                  ing  is  coming  entirely  from  the  ma-
                                                                                                                          chine. My creative thinking has defi-
                                                                                   By Justin Tai                          nitely weakened,” he says.
                                                                                                                             Like Lau, Liu is drawn to using AI
                                                                                                                          for better grades and efficiency.
                                                                                                                             “Doing   coursework   ourselves
                                                                                                                          surely helps hone our skills, but Ge-
                                                                                                                          nAI boosts my efficiency so much. I
                                                                                                                          can now finish a paper in less than an   University student Lau Tsz Ho uses GenAI to tackle science problems on his
                                                                                                                          hour. It used to take me a whole day.   laptop (Photo Courtesy of Lau Tsz Ho)
                                                                                                                          Sometimes its ideas are even better
           University student Lau Tsz Ho  universities for  research  and learn-  by the UK-based Higher  Education       than mine. It’s hard to turn the clock   Despite the convenience, Chu is   Fang stresses that a university de-
        used to spend hours or even days  ing support. However, they admit  Policy Institute, 88 percent of students      back,” the Year 2 student says.    aware of the potential risks of the  gree is not just about completing as-
        struggling to solve difficult science  they find that despite following these  in  the UK had used GenAI tools for   “It saves time and my grades have  overreliance on GenAI.           signments or passing exams.
        questions from classes. He might not  guidelines, they have doubts about  their assessments, from explaining      improved.  But  I wonder  if  I’m  trad-  “Although I enjoy everything Ge-  “It should show a student knows
        find the answers in the end, but he still  whether they are truly learning or just  complex concepts to brainstorming   ing away my ability to think for con-  nAI offers, I worry that we’ll stop us-  how to learn, has been part of a learn-
        tried hard.                         prompting their way through GenAI.  research ideas.                           venience. That’s what makes me feel  ing our brains to think and learn. It  ing community, and can critically
           Now, he just feeds the questions he   “I feel like I’m not using my brain   In Hong Kong, universities are     stupid, even when I’m doing well in  could be dangerous for humankind  reflect on their lives and society,” he
        cannot solve to Generative Artificial  anymore. I feel dumber the more I  responding  to  this  shift cautiously.   terms of my grades,” he adds.    and society if people aren’t aware of  says.
        Intelligence, better known as GenAI,  rely on AI for schoolwork,” he shares.  All eight public universities now of-  Chu  Ka Hai, a  postgraduate stu-  what’s happening or why, and just        Edited By Kieon Paek
                                                                                                                                                                                                         Edited By Kieon Paek
        and gets instant answers with a smart   “I basically just dump questions to  fer access to an array of GenAI tools   dent researching artificial intelligence,  keep being fed information by AI,” he   Sub-edited By Myo Min Htin
                                                                                                                                                                                                  Sub-edited By Myo Min Htin
        device in his hand.                 GenAI and hope for the best. Whether  designed to support student learn-      believes  GenAI  makes  him  do  less  adds.
           “GenAI is not just a tool. It’s my  it’s about solving complex equations,  ing, from writing assistants to coding   thinking, despite his rich knowledge   Professor Fang Kecheng of the
        lifesaver. A messiah,” the science ma-  writing lab reports, or preparing Pow-  tools. These tools are integrated under   about technology.          School  of Journalism  and Commu-
        jor student says.                   erPoint presentations,” he says.   each institution’s ethical guidelines,        “I used to struggle a lot with long  nication at The Chinese University of
           “If AI disappeared tomorrow, I’d    “Sometimes I don’t even know  which emphasise transparency, aca-           essays. So I turned to AI to help me  Hong Kong, who researches the role
        probably be kicked out of my univer-  what the machine is talking about,  demic integrity, and responsible use.   check grammar and develop my ide-  of technologies such as AI in shap-
        sity. Without it, my grades would fall,  but it sounds smart, so I go with it,”   Another  university  student, Liu   as. After that, I couldn’t resist using it  ing the media landscape, warns heavy
        and I wouldn’t be able to work out an-  he adds.                       Sai Ho was sceptical about the use of      anymore,” Chu shares.              reliance on GenAI might disconnect
        swers for my study on my own,” the     Yet, his grade cards show a differ-  GenAI at first, but his view changed     “I can’t write grammatically correct  students from the vital experience of
        Year 2 student says.                ent story. “I used to get Bs and Cs.  after GenAI helped him score A- for     paragraphs in English without GenAI  learning and intellectual growth.
           Students like Lau emphasise that  Now, I’m seeing As and A-minuses,  an assignment.                            now. I tried once doing it on my own,   “Learning should be difficult, and
        they use GenAI in accordance with  even though I’m not actually learning   “I was hesitant at first. GenAI gives   and my draft was full of grammar  even painful. No pain, no gain. If stu-
        the course outlines provided by their  anything,” he says.             you answers so fast that I don’t need      slips and awkward phrasing. It’s easier  dents avoid this pain by relying on AI,

                                               According to a 2025 survey done  to process anything in my head. I was     to let AI sort it out for me. But that  they might lose their interest in any
   33   34   35   36   37   38   39   40   41   42   43