Home Blog Page 18

Shopping Green

More consumers buy used clothes from second-hand shops.

Yap Ying-ye

Going one step further

High school student Chiara Jeong started running an online Instagram shop selling her second-hand clothes four years ago. Her account has about 2,500 followers.

“I started my shop because I had many clothes I had never worn and I wanted to make some money. After doing research about fast fashion, I find that waste problem in the fashion industry is serious. That is why I also use my online shop to promote sustainability.”, she says. 

Jeong explains problems caused by fast fashion on Instagram to promote second-hand clothes and to raise public awareness about the importance of environmental protection. 

Chiara Jeong uses her online shop to promote sustainability.
(Photo courtesy of Chiara Jeong)

Hong Kong generates an average of 392 tonnes of textile waste every day, about 50 per cent of which is estimated to be clothing, according to the Environmental Protection Department’s Statistics Units in 2020.

“Judging from my business, I think consumers are more eco-friendly when buying clothes. I have gained roughly 400 customers and have made around 900 sales over the past four years,” she says. 

Going second-hand

Sharing the same view with Jeong, University student Kelly Wong started to buy second-hand two years ago because of sustainability and cheaper prices. 

“I once found a high quality second-hand floral dress for just HKD $20 (USD $3). It looks just as good as new,” Wong says. 

She thinks second-hand shopping is gaining popularity in Hong Kong.

“Some key opinion leaders in Hong Kong talk about cute clothes they have found at second-hand stores. My friends and I also like to go thrifting together,” Wong says. 

Many Hong Kong YouTubers, such as Pomato with about 436,000 subscribers and Yaki Wong with about 236,000 subscribers, have made videos promoting second-hand clothing stores to their audience.  

“I think this is good as it breaks down misconceptions about second-hand clothing. It is wrong to see second-hand clothing as dirty and clothes for the poor,” Wong says.

“I think this is good as it breaks down misconceptions about second-hand clothing. It is wrong to see second-hand clothing as dirty and clothes for the poor”

Changing attitudes, persisting problem

Tiffany Wong Nga-yung, who has operated an online and a physical second-hand clothing shop for two years also thinks buying second-hand clothes has become a trend. 

“People are more eco-conscious nowadays, especially since being environmentally friendly has become something cool and trendy amongst younger people,” Wong says. 

Ninety-five per cent of respondents aged under 35 purchased second-hand products, according to a purchasing habits study conducted by Carousell, an online platform for exchanging second-hand goods and The Interactive Advertising Bureau of Southeast Asia and India, a non-profit organization, in 2021. 

The poll surveyed a total of 3,500 consumers in Singapore, Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia and Hong Kong. 

The findings also show respondents aged under 35 cared more about environmental issues, such as sustainability and climate change when compared with those aged over 35.

But Wong says overconsumption remains a problem. Her shop had to stop collecting used clothes until December 2021, as the amount was too overwhelming.

“We offer a wardrobe clean-out service where we collect unwanted second-hand clothing from customers for reselling. But we had to stop the service because there were too many clothes to sort through,” Wong says. 

“It takes time photographing and modeling the clothes collected, as well as waiting for customers to purchase,” she adds.

Tiffany Wong Nga-yung’s second hand store offers a wardrobe clean-out service for customers’ unwanted clothes.
(Photo courtesy of Tiffany Wong Nga-yung)

Wong advises consumers to think of new ways to style their clothes, instead of throwing them away.

“If you only have one picture in your mind, you might not be able to find what you want from second-hand shops. Sometimes, second-hand items will surprise you.” Wong says. 

Looking Ahead 

Ki Chung-wha, assistant professor from the Institute of Textiles and Clothing of the Hong Kong Polytechnic University, says the shift in attitude towards second-hand shopping is because of easier access to second-hand clothing.

“Thanks to technological developments, many online platforms such as Facebook marketplaces have been set up for second-hand trading,” Ki says. 

“People used to have misconceptions about second-hand shopping, which is seen to be related to people with low economic status. Online platforms allow people to feel more comfortable trading second-hand goods,” she adds. 

Ki thinks consumers should buy less and support the second-hand market and circular fashion, which means having sustainable production to reduce waste.

“We cannot control consumer’s purchasing habits, so we need more education and campaigns to raise awareness amongst consumers,” she adds. 

Edited by Winkie Ng
Sub-edited by Leung Pak-hei

Modern slavery in China: Overwork Culture

IT talents lament their life of toil.

Kossy Chen

Working 12 hours a day without overtime payment for six years, Elva Lei, a 38-year-old IT manager, has to attend online meetings even after 11 p.m. when she is home.

“I feel exhausted. I find it very difficult to balance work and family. I have more work after my promotion six years ago,” the mother of a two-year-old daughter says. 

“When I have late-night meetings at home, my child wakes up when she hears me talking. My husband then fights with me,” she sighs. 

Working until 2 a.m. with less than six hours of sleep is her routine. 

Lei suffered from insomnia two years ago when she was pregnant, often thinking about work affairs after midnight. 

She also suffered from postpartum depression after giving birth. “I often forgot what I wanted to say and cried secretly in the office because of work stress,” she recalls. 

She wants to find another job. “But I am almost 40, It is difficult for me to find a better job that suits me,” she says. 

Elva Lei has late-night meetings and work at home.
(Photo courtesy of Elva Lei)

A New Mode of Labour Time Control

The International Labour Organization set out the principle of the 40-hour workweek, with a maximum of eight hours per day as an international norm in 1919. 

This rule also came into effect in the Labour Law of the People’s Republic of China on May 1, 1995. 

But the guideline on working hours has been gradually replaced by the “996” working hour system, which is practiced by many Chinese internet and technology companies, meaning employees work from 9 am to 9 pm, six days a week.

On April 11, 2019, the former executive chairman of Alibaba Group, Jack Ma, gave a speech about the system to his employees in a meeting.

 “Today China’s BAT (Baidu, Alibaba, Tencent)  adopt” 996” . I think it is a blessing on us. If you do not put in more efforts and time than others, how can you achieve success?” he says. 

Critics like Jenny Wang points out that the 996 working hour system is a violation of Chinese labour law and calls it “modern slavery.”

According to a report released in January 2021 by 36kr, a China-based publishing and data company, only 10 per cent out of over 4,000 young people surveyed said they never work overtime and did not respond to work messages after office hours. 

Fake Experience of Freedom

Some companies take the initiative to reduce work hours. Giant tech company ByteDance abandoned its  “big and small week” work arrangement from August 1, 2021. 

Employees used to work six days a week ,two times a month. Now they all have Saturdays off. Many other internet companies have followed suit. 

Despite the policy change, Sophia Zhang, 25, still thinks it is a losing battle for workers to fight against long working hours.

“I still go to work on Saturdays voluntarily because overtime payment is quite high and I want to make more money. Also, I want to get promotions,” Zhang, who has been working at ByteDance for two years, says.

“I often go home after 10 p.m. I can claim taxi fees from the company when I leave the office after 10 p.m., and sometimes I work at home until 2 to 3 a.m.,” she says.

Sophia Zhang eats a quick lunch before busy work in the afternoon.
(Photo courtesy of Sophia Zhang)

Zhang suffers from endocrine disorder because of long working hours. “I only get my period once every two or three months. I want to go out on weekends, but I don’t know where to go. It seems I have lost my passion for life,” she adds.

“I only get my period once every two or three months. I want to go out on weekends, but I don’t know where to go. It seems I have lost my passion for life.”

Rebuilding Self-worth

Former Bytedance employee Leon Zhang, who was also overworked, resigned from the giant tech company in 2020 to start a new life. 

The 26-year-old IT talent joined a small company working on knowledge-sharing platforms instead. 

“If overwork is inevitable, I will only work for a company in which I can explore my full potential. I felt depressed and mentally tortured when working aimlessly every day in my previous post,” he says.

“If overwork is inevitable, I will only work for a company in which I can explore my full potential. I felt depressed and mentally tortured when working aimlessly every day in my previous post.”

He worked more than 12 hours each day at Bytedance and had no time for dating and rest.

“We had to respond to messages from our supervisors even when we were home. There was no difference between staying at home or being in the office, “he adds.

Zhang acknowledges that his former employer tries to cultivate their can-do attitudes by challenging their limits. But he did not feel a sense of achievement when he worked there.

“My current job is to pass on knowledge and values to the public, which is meaningful and gives me a sense of self-value,” he says. 

Combatting Overwork

Ma Liang, a professor from the Public Administration Faculty at the Renmin University of China, believes overwork is a systematic problem in China.

He points out overwork is a reflection of “involution” (內卷), which is a buzzword broadly used to describe meaningless competitions in China.

“I don’t think individual employees can resist this ongoing trend, as giant companies have strong bargaining power and the government does not want to affect economic growth by strictly enforcing labour protection laws,” Ma says.

“Some individuals even enjoy overwork because they want financial independence and early retirement is popular among entrepreneurs,” he continues.

“However, given the increasing salience of maternity policy in the upcoming years, governments may urge companies to implement more employee-friendly measures, and overwork might be addressed to some extent,” he adds.

Sub-edited by Kajal Aidasani

Scent of Darkness

A blind man gets his life back with a fragrance company.

Phoebe Chu

Holding his guide dog, Wan Tsz-Yin sets off to his fragrance company. From Tuen Mun to Prince Edward, his flurry companion Remy accompanies him, so that he can walk faster to catch a bus without hitting obstacles along the way.

“Remy now stays home during the pandemic to avoid infection. So sometimes I have to go to work alone,” say Wan, whose left eye has blurred vision and his right eye is completely blind.

At 10:00 am, the 32-year-old fragrance company founder starts doing measurements and mixing essential oils of different flavors together with cream to create products with different functions.

“I can easily tell the smell of lavender and orange, but I always mix up pine and cedar. It takes time to remember all the scents I work with,” he says. 

Wan’s company has six products including aroma oil, lipsticks, hand cream and mask diffusers. Anti-allergy hand cream is the best seller.

Accurate measurement is the key to making aroma oil. But it is a difficult task for Wan and his colleagues.  

As the concentration of essential oils varies in different products, the speed of adding them has to be adjusted. Wan says his team has spent a lot of time looking for the best apparatus for accurate measurement.

“Most of my colleagues are only left with around 10% of their eyesight. We use small droppers to have better control of the amount of essential oil added. Colleagues who have better vision do measurement while others pack products,” Wan says. 

“We also have to hire someone from an accountant firm to handle paperwork for our company registration, as all of us cannot read due to eyesight problems,” Wan says. 

Stalls set up by Wan and his team at a secondary school to sell and promote their products
(Photo Courtesy of Wan Tsz-Yin)

A Sudden Heavy Blow

Wan was not born blind. In 2008, he was diagnosed with a brain tumor that pinched his nerve, causing his blindness. He was 19. 

“I was admitted to a hospital for a few months. I did not expect that I would be blind at that time,” he says.

Wan recalled his whole world turned “black in color” when he stepped out of the hospital.

“I felt like I was a burden to my family. I stayed home most of the time for the first six months after being discharged. I felt worthless as I could not take care of myself. I could not even eat on my own. I cried every day,” he says.

His family sought help from some non-governmental organizations (NGOs) which offers help to people with eyesight problems.

“People there (NGOs) taught me some basic life skills such as taking showers and dining. I started learning how to take care of myself,” Wan recalls. 

Wan says it took him three to four years to accept the fact that he is blind and move on.

He started joining different rehabilitation courses in the same year, such as learning how to be a visually impaired massage therapist.

“But I still did not know what I could do in the future at that time. I wondered if massage therapist was the only thing I could do,” Wan says.

Data from Census and Statistics Department of Hong Kong Government shows that the unemployment rate among people with eyesight difficulty in 2021 was 88.8 per cent.

There were about 47,600 people in Hong Kong who had eyesight difficulty, accounting for 0.6 per cent of the Hong Kong population in 2021.

A New Career Path

Wan eventually did not work as a massage therapist and founded his fragrance company in 2021.

“My friend asked me to use lavender aroma oil to put myself into a good sleep when I came across some family problems back in 2016,” Wan says.

After using fragrance products for six years, he joined a fragrance making course and a teacher there joined her students to set up their fragrance company.

“I think it might be a new career path for the visually impaired, so I want to give it a try and see if it works out for me. That is how I started my company,” he says.

Wan is also thinking about starting his own social enterprise, offering more job opportunities to people with eyesight problems to work together.

“I hope it can provide a working environment for people with visual difficulty where they do not have to worry about making mistakes and being discriminated. A workplace that will help them thrive,” Wan says.

Sub-edited by Leung Pak-hei

You May Say I’m A Dreamer – Editor’s Note

A career in the entertainment industry has always fascinated many people. Many of them decided to put in determined efforts to pursue their dreams of being on stage.

Our Periscope section follows the stories of passionate youngsters as they aspire to become singers. Hong Kong’s popular reality show King Maker has inspired many Hongkongers to strive to become the city’s next popular idol, while many others have attended training by South Korean entertainment groups as they fight for fame.

This issue of Varsity also explores many other interesting issues and phenomena, from the rise of takeaway food in Hong Kong amid the Covid-19 pandemic and social media detox, to the Chinese government’s anti-scam app and its crackdown on erotic novels.

Have an enjoyable read!

Leung Pak-hei

Chief Editor

Stop Working Hard, ‘Lie Flat’

Young people “lie flat” to fight against rat race.

Iris Jiang

Lisa Yiu*, a year two student studying childhood education at the Education University of Hong Kong, has decided to “lie flat” due to exhaustion from hard work and competition with classmates. 

“My grades worsened no matter how hard I tried, so I decided to adopt a ‘lying flat’ lifestyle,” the higher diploma student says, adding that she finds the grading system not transparent and it is not worth the effort to get better grades.

“Lying flat” is a lifestyle which promotes doing the minimum for a living. Yiu takes it as a fightback against society’s pressure to perform well. She is content with her current situation and refuses to overwork.

“I still want to learn. But I will not burn the midnight oil for schoolwork anymore,” the student says.

“The government just does not understand us. There is no use in condemning us or telling us not to ‘lie flat’ unless they actually do something to make us feel hopeful,” she adds.

Hong Kong Government’s Response 

The Education Bureau released an article on its official website on November 28, 2021 stating the recent emergence of “lying flatism” is worrying. It also stated that this kind of negative mentality could easily make people decadent and would hinder the progress of society in the long run.

In a written reply to Varsity, a bureau spokesperson says: “One of the major emphases in the curriculum framework is adding “diligence” to the existing list of values and attitudes.” These values also include perseverance, national identity and law-abidingness. 

“Diligence does not mean overworking, but a time-honoured positive value which can motivate students to work hard since childhood,” the reply states.

Hong Kong’s Education Bureau added “diligence” into values education in November 2021.

From Appearing to Disappearing

The buzzword “lying flat” sprang up when a 31-year-old jobless man Luo Huazhong released his article “‘Lying Flat’ is Justice” on Baidu Tieba, an online platform that gathers people with common interests by searching keywords, in April 2021. 

Luo shared how he lived in his comfort zone while being unemployed for two years. “It doesn’t feel wrong…’Lying flat’ is my wiseman philosophy,” he wrote in the article.

The idea of “lying flat” promotes: “Don’t buy property and a car. Don’t get married. Don’t have children. Don’t consume.”

In response to the “lying flat” lifestyle, Nanfang Daily, a Chinese state media, published an article entitled “Lying Flat is Shameful, There is Nothing to Feel Righteous About” on May 20, 2021. The article accused negative emotions spread by “lying flat” practitioners while encouraging the public to be confident about their future.

“It is necessary to prevent the stagnation of social classes…and form an environment for improvement in which everyone participates, avoiding involution and ‘lying flat’,” wrote the Chinese President Xi Jinping on October 15, 2021 in Qiushi, the leading official journal on political theory of the Chinese Communist Party.

As the state media has made their position clear, Luo’s article was removed by censors, “lying flat” discussion groups in Chinese social media were shut down and the search function for the term has been disabled.

Finding Comfort Zone

Though the Chinese government tried to suppress discussions, Taiwanese businessman Mark Zheng* set up a Facebook group entitled “Lying Flatism” on June 20, 2021. The group promotes “lying flat” lifestyles with over 100 members, mainly from Taiwan.

Cover of Mark Zheng’s Facebook group “Lying Flatism”.
(Photo courtesy of Mark Zheng)

“I want to provide a safe and comfortable platform for people to express their opinion,” Zheng says. He has observed that many have been complaining about pressure from work. He thinks that “lying flat” is a kind of spiritual resistance to rat races and the exploitation from employers.

Zheng only works one hour a day on average in an international trade company, with a monthly salary around 40,000 Taiwan dollars (US$1410). He brands himself as a “‘lying flat’ practitioner”. 

“I am content with my life and I do not think that I need to work harder,” the 36-year-old businessman says, adding that everyone can choose whatever lifestyle he or she wants.

Making it Discussible

To show support for the “‘lying flat’ lifestyle”, Zhang Jiumin*, a Chinese independent songwriter, released a song “Lying Flat Is Kingly Way” on Weibo and YouTube. The song lists some benefits of “lying flat” such as preventing burning out and maintaining people’s physical and mental health. 

Video cover of Zhang Jiumin’s song “Lying Flat Is Kingly Way”.
(Photo courtesy of Zhang Jiu-min)

Despite being removed from Weibo, a popular social media platform in China, he keeps posting the song by not using sensitive words such as “lying flat” in his description to avoid censorship.

“I just want more people to listen to my song. It is written from the bottom of my heart. Although ‘lying flat’ is not a mainstream value, it should still be discussed,” Zhang says. 

Lau Siu-lun, a lecturer of Sociology in the Chinese University of Hong Kong, points out that “lying flatism” is not a new idea, citing the “Beat Generation” from the United States in the 1950s and the “Low-Desire Society” concept from Japan in the 1990s as examples.

“Living costs increase with economic development, while pay rise fails to catch up. The Chinese working class in first-tier cities like Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou and Shengzhen find it less rewarding to live and work in these competitive places,” he explains.

Lau points out that people feel stressed when they work for long hours but still cannot afford housing property, while the price of daily commodities keeps rising.

“I think some of them will just give up their regular jobs in first-tier cities and return to their hometown or other second or third-tier cities to enjoy a more relaxing lifestyle,” Lau says.

*Names changed at interviewees’ request.

Edited by Leung Pak-hei
Sub-edited by Kajal Aidasani

Why they say no to vaccine?

Some university students resist mandatory vaccination on campuses.

Amelie Yeung

Refusing to be vaccinated because of possible side effects, university student Reyna Wong* has to do self-tests every two weeks in order to attend lectures at the Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK) campus. 

“I have heard from my friends of their friends having abnormal and heavy periods after receiving the vaccine. I think women are more vulnerable to these side effects,” Wong, who is pursuing her master’s degree, says.

For Wong, the announcement of mandatory vaccination by CUHK in January means she may opt for suspension of studies. 

“I will wait until the pandemic is over to continue my study. I will not get the COVID-19 vaccine no matter what,” she says.

As of 8 March, there are 497,000 reported cases in Hong Kong. Due to the outbreak, all universities have announced that classes will be conducted virtually. 

In January, the CUHK Emergency Response Group announced that all persons on the university campus must have received at least one dose of COVID-19 vaccination. Otherwise, their enrolment in both physical and online classes will be cancelled. 

CUHK’s announcement of mandatory vaccination in January.

Other universities in Hong Kong have implemented similar measures. 

The Hong Kong Baptist University required all students and staff to be vaccinated by late October last year. The University of Hong Kong (HKU) also requires anyone who enters the campus to be fully vaccinated starting from February.

Wong joined a Telegram group with over 1,700 members in late December last year to discuss ways to fight against the CUHK’s vaccination policy.

Chat group members exchange information about the virus, university policy and government measures. 

“There are many reasons why students remain unvaccinated, like having medical concerns, and lacking trust in the vaccines’ effectiveness. Some believe we should have body autonomy,” Wong says.

She relies on the group for emotional support. “Without it, I may have gave in already. But being in the group and surrounded by like-minded people reminds me of the dangers of taking the jab,” she says. 

The logo of the Telegram group opposing mandatory vaccination in CUHK.

In October, the chat group filed a petition voicing objection against mandatory COVID-19 vaccination or testing required by CUHK. It gathered over 2,700 signatures from students, staff members, and alumni. 

The petition letter called for students and staff to boycott CUHK’s online vaccination report form.

Facing the tightening restrictions of CUHK, the group sent an open letter objecting to the university forcing COVID-19 vaccinations to President Rocky Tuan Sung-chi and CUHK Emergency Response Group in February. The university management has not responded to the group.

Side effects of COVID-19 vaccines

But science does not agree with the group.

In February 2021, the Centres for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in the United States found that six people developed a blood clotting disorder after receiving the Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccines, among the 6.8 million people who were vaccinated.

In April, CDC recommended that vaccination be resumed because the side effects are rare and the benefits outweigh the risks.

There is no evidence suggesting that the COVID-19 vaccine will affect menstruation cycles. 

In July 2021, Clara Paik, clinic medical director of obstetrics and gynaecology at the University of California (UC) Davis Health, an academic medical centre based in the U.S., suggested that changes to women’s menstrual cycle may be due to the stress of vaccinating.

Despite these findings, CUHK student Mary Fu* is still not convinced.

“My concern is that the vaccine may cause gene mutation. The vaccines are so new and no one knows what side effects it may bring. What if the changes surface decades later? It will be too late by then and our entire generation will be plagued by them,” Fu says.

The 21-year-old student also questions the protection rate of the vaccine. “Being vaccinated does not mean you will not get Omicron,” she says, referring to the latest variant of COVID-19.

A joint study by CUHK and HKU last December found that the protection rate of Comirnaty and CoronaVac vaccines are greatly reduced against Omicron, compared with previous variants. The amount of virus neutralising antibody levels in blood were less than that of the protective threshold.

But a third dose of Comirnaty vaccine provides protection levels of antibody against Omicron, while CoronaVac vaccine does not, according to the study.

Fear of Needles

Apart from health concerns, Alice Chan*, an undergraduate student at CUHK, refuses to take jabs due to fear of needles.

She recalls once being tied down by nurses when receiving injections for a nervous breakdown in 2017. 

“It was traumatic. I was hysterical and cried and screamed for hours. I begged the nurses not to give me the injection, but they did not listen. Even recalling it now leaves my left arm weak and heavy,” Chan says.

Since then, the year two student cannot face being injected with anything again. 

She has obtained medical proof for exemption from COVID-19 vaccination due to her unstable mental condition.

Tightening Restrictions

In the United Kingdom, 85 per cent of university students have received two doses of COVID-19 vaccine, according to a study by the Office of National Statistics in December 2021. 

In contrast, the percentage of Hongkongers who have received two doses is 62 per cent, according to Our World in Data, a publication with its research team based in Oxford in December 2021.

To boost vaccination rate, the Hong Kong government has rolled out a vaccine pass, under which only vaccinated individuals will be allowed to enter facilities such as restaurants and malls starting from February 24. 

Professor Lancelot Mui Wai-ho, a lecturer at CUHK’s Jockey Club School of Public Health and Primary Care, says he understands students’ concerns about the side effects of COVID-19 vaccine but notes they should get the jab.

“Globally, we have now administered over 10 billion doses of the vaccine. Our understanding of the vaccine is now much better than the early days,” he says.

“COVID-19 vaccination is about risks versus benefits. Without a clear and present threat of COVID-19 infection, students will focus on the possible side effects of vaccines and think that the risks outweigh the benefits,” Mui says.

“Vaccination is the only scientifically proven way to effectively protect society from getting overwhelmed by COVID-19,” he adds.

Mui asserts that taking the vaccine is not only for our own benefit. “If not enough people are vaccinated, the virus will continue to circulate in the community, and people who cannot be vaccinated will suffer,” he says.

“Taking the vaccine now will save the lives of many in the future,” he says.

The CUHK Medical Centre, one of the many healthcare institutions in Hong Kong that offers COVID-19 vaccination.

*Names changed at interviewees’ request.

Sub-edited by Leung Pak-hei

A good deal : Rice with two dishes

Takeaway shops selling rice with two dishes are thriving amid the pandemic. 

Carrie Lock

While the catering industry is struggling to survive in the pandemic, some start their business selling takeaway meals with rice and two dishes to turn misfortune into fortune.  One of them is Hong Kongers Family Food (香港人兩餸飯), a family-run food business which opened in September 2021. 

“Customers prefer buying takeaway food to reduce infection risk. Our business has benefited from government restriction which bans dining-in after 6pm,” Ada Tsang Wai-yi, the 26-year-old daughter of the takeaway shop owner says.

“We were worried about the risk of running a takeaway food shop amid the pandemic. Our family needs to make a living. We thought the pandemic would not affect takeaway food shops much, so we decided to move our business to Quarry Bay as planned,” she continues.

Tsang’s family operated a takeaway food shop selling rice with two dishes in Tseung Kwan O for two years until July 2021. They now continue running it in Quarry Bay, where many offices are located, due to lease expiry.

The takeaway shop sells around 250 to 300 meal boxes a day, each box costing HK$32. 

“Our shop is mostly visited by white collar workers. During lunch hour, there is always a long queue outside our shop,” Tsang says.

Customers are queueing outside “Hong Kongers Family Food” in Quarry Bay during lunch hour.

The number of food factory licence applications increased from 1,528 in 2019 to 2,021 in 2021, according to the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department. All takeaway eateries selling rice with two dishes with no seating are required to apply for the food factory licenses. 

It took half a year for Tsang’s shop to apply for the license. “We hired a license consultant to help us with the license application so the whole process was easier,” Tsang says.

Competition is getting intense when more takeaway shops selling rice with two dishes join the market. Tsang’s shop faces three competitors in Quarry Bay.

“Our shop is in a small alley whereas other takeaway shops are in the main street. In the first month, we did not earn much as not many people noticed our shop,” Tsang says.

“We joined different food delivery platforms and launch new dishes every month to attract and retain customers. Gradually, the profit grows. Our turnover is now over HK$100,000 every month,” she adds. 

A meal box with two dishes – chicken wings and radishes with pig blood curds and fishballs.

Rice with two dishes going viral online

The popularity of takeaway shops selling rice with two dishes spikes online. Andrew Wong Yuk-hay, a 44-year-old social worker, set up a Facebook concern group about rice with two dishes in December 2020. The group has about 65,000 members.

Wong says 5,000 Facebook users requested to join the rice with two dishes concern group within ten days after the government announced banning dine-in services after 6pm in restaurants on 5 January. 

“I think takeaway food has become popular mainly because of the government ban on dine-in services after 6pm. Many people get off from work late, so they tend to buy takeaway food,” Wong says.

Wong recalls he had rice with two dishes at a factory canteen for the first time when he was a Form Seven student working as a summer part-timer in Ngau Tau Kok.

A map of takeaway shops selling rice with two dishes with information about pricing and shop location is created based on information Wong gathered from his Facebook group members.

A map of takeaway shops selling rice with two dishes including information about pricing and shop location.

The cheapest meal plan of rice with two dishes is sold at HK$17, while the most expensive one costs HK$55. Sham Shui Po, Yau Tsim Mong and Tuen Mun districts are the districts with the most takeaway food shops, according to the map.

“A lot of people want to know whether there are any takeaway food shops near their neighbourhood. The Facebook group can provide them with this information,” he says.

“I am motivated to run the group as rice with two dishes connects people with different backgrounds and political stances, allowing them to communicate without hostility,” he adds.

Wong also shares a dish picking tip. “It is wiser to order meat patties or steamed fish. The shop operator cannot secretly give you less portions as the customers can count the number of meat patties and fish in their meal box,” he says.

Leung Chung-hei, a 29 year-old driver, joined the group in December 2020. He says he did not consume rice with two dishes frequently before the outbreak of COVID-19.

“I eat it more often during the pandemic because there are more shops selling rice with two dishes which provide consumers with more choices,” Leung says. 

Leung takes pictures of rice boxes he bought and shares eateries information in the Facebook group. “My favourites are chicken wings and fried chicken with lemon sauce,” he says.

Cheap price is another reason why he consumes rice with two dishes more frequently.

“Nowadays, it costs at least HK$40 to buy a lunch box with only one dish from a fast food chain restaurant. It is wiser and cheaper to buy rice with two dishes from takeaway shops,” Leung says. 

An affordable option for grassroots

Rachel Lau Yin-shan, a community organiser of the Society for Community Organisation (SoCO), says takeaway shops selling rice with two dishes provide an affordable option to help ease financial burden of the grassroots.

“The demand for rice with two dishes has indeed increased under economic recession. The salary of the grassroots has been reduced and the minimum wage has not been reviewed for three years. Their income cannot catch up with the inflation rate,” she says.

“The demand for rice with two dishes has indeed increased under economic recession. The salary of the grassroots has been reduced and the minimum wage has not been reviewed for three years. Their income cannot catch up with the inflation rate,” she says.

Lau points out many low-income households working in retailing, catering and construction are troubled by unemployment, underemployment and leave without pay during the pandemic.

“Working mums have to stay home looking after their children as online lessons are conducted. They cannot work to make money,” she says.

“As the government banned dine-in services after 6pm, there are more takeaway shops selling rice with two dishes at a cheap price. Grassroot customers find it more cost-effective to buy takeaway than cooking at home,” Lau adds.

Customers are choosing which cheap meal boxes to savour.

Health tips from Dietitian

Registered dietitian Chloe Lee Wai-hang offers some health tips for eating rice with two dishes.

“The choice of dishes matters most. If we select two dishes with high calories, we may gain weight,” Lee says. 

She points out that dishes with excess fat, high sugar and sodium levels are unhealthy as well. Absorbing excess saturated fat and trans-fat may raise people’s cholesterol level, while food with high sugar and sodium levels may increase people’s blood glucose level and blood pressure.

“Steamed pork patty with salted egg yolk, sweet and sour pork and scrambled eggs with shrimps are the top three unhealthy dishes,” she says.

Lee says the best combination for a rice box with two dishes is to order one vegetable dish and one meat dish. 

“Mushrooms, broccoli, celery, tofu and bitter cucumber are good choices. Also, avoid choosing fatty meat like meat patties and beef briskets, lean meat such as fish and chicken fillet would be a healthier choice, “she says. 

The Five Healthiest Dishes (Average calories) per 100g
Shiitake mushroom with broccoli 北菇西蘭花 (48 kcal)
Stir-fried chicken fillet with celery 西芹炒雞柳 (92 kcal)
Stir-fried bitter melon and beef 涼瓜炒牛肉 (94 kcal)
Stir-fried fish fillet with broccoli 西蘭花炒魚塊 (110 kcal)
Spring beans with minced pork 欖菜肉鬆四季豆 (130 kcal)

Edited by Angel Woo
Sub-edited by Leung Pak-hei

Too Sexy To Tell?

Chinese writers’ witty fight against government censorship.

Eve Qiao

Lucien Dong is a freelance writer of Jinjiang Literature City, a leading digital platform of online novels in China. Her first novel about a love story of two gay men was taken down by the website in early 2020 because it was said to contain pornographic content.

 “I am still upset about this. I do not understand why my writing was taken down. I do not know how to fight my case, as this is my first time posting online,” the 20-year-old university student says. 

Message for Lucien Dong from Jinjiang: Sorry, relevant chapter is banned or deleted by web administrator due to contents of obscenity, indecency or plagiarism. (Photo courtesy of Lucien Dong)

Her novel was banned due to description of sexual intercourse of two homosexual lovers in a few chapters. 

“The description comes in naturally to fit the story plot. The website operator asks me to remove the part about sexual intercourse, but then my story will be incomplete,” she says.

Not only Dong’s fiction was taken down because of sexual content, other online publication websites including Qidian Platform in China have similar practices. They issue guidelines stating novels should not have sexual elements. 

Jinjiang’s restriction on pornography

Grace Huang, who vetted written work for online novel websites from 2019 to 2021, says censorship is a serious problem for online publication.

“It is strange to me that sex actions below the neck are not allowed to be depicted,” she says. 

“I passed a chapter containing a depiction of neck kiss in 2019. But it was still banned in the final round of censorship,” she recalls. 

The 22-year-old part-time censor says censorship has become stricter in recent years.

In 2013, focus of the “Clean Up the Internet” campaign organised by the Ministry of Public Security was changed from online criminal activity to cleaning up pornographic content according to the Cyberspace Administration of China. It was said to protect young users. 

To avoid censorship, writers such as Veronica Liu, who has been writing for two years, choose to publish her work on an overseas website to enjoy the freedom of creation.

First page of an overseas online novel website

“As the Chinese government continues to strengthen online content censorship, many authors and I feel frustrated about these restrictions,” Liu says. 

“I write books to express myself, and I will not change my expression or ideas because of suppression,” she adds.

She has to use Virtual Private Network (VPN) to access the overseas website in China.

“It is getting more difficult to use VPN because restrictions are getting stringent,” the 20-year-old freelance writer says.

Laws in mainland China specify the use of VPN as illegal and it is subjected to a fine of up to RMB ¥15,000 (US $2,360).

“I am worried about the future of online novels. I am also worried that maybe one day I cannot even publish my work on the overseas website,” Liu sighs.

After some chapters of Lucien Dong’s novel were taken down, she told her readers she could send the banned chapters through email to them. (Photo courtesy of Lucien Dong)

Another writer, Claudia Wang, who has been writing online fiction for nine years, finds other ways to maximise her freedom to write.

“We create social media groups in which we post our writing,” Wang says.

She says there are other ways to avoid censorship, including posting upside-down text of novels or using messy code as file names of novels when sharing online.

“Censors cannot recognise upside-down text and internet police will not find files with messy code as novels’ names,” Wang says. 

 “Writers always find ways to make sure their work can be published in its original shape. Creation is immortal,” she adds.

Katrien Jacobs, associate professor from the Department of Cultural and Religious Studies at the Chinese University of Hong Kong, thinks sexual content is necessary for erotic novels. 

“Many people want to share their sexual experiences and fantasies. It is generally a sign of a healthy culture,” Jacobs says. 

“They are not just writing about sex. They are thinking about the future of sex,” the senior researcher of pornographic culture adds.

 Jacob thinks censorship not only occurs in China.

“Some other countries have similar restrictions. However, I think the government can give erotic novels some room to grow,” she says.

But she is still optimistic about the future of online novels in China.

“Sometimes it makes writers feel sad, but it also means that they have to think about other ways of producing (novels). They may feel it is the end of the world when a new rule comes, but there is so much out there to look at,” Jacob says.

“I feel like there will always be a balance between the rules and how people reacting creatively. The imagination cannot be really stopped,” she adds.

Edited by Alina Chen
Sub-edited by Winkie Ng

Social Media Detox

Many have tried social media detox for better physical and mental well-being.

Karmen Yip

University student Edith Yeung Tsz-ning stopped using Instagram and Facebook for 10 days before her examination in November 2021 to focus on her studies.

“My learning efficiency was much improved as I was less distracted during my social media detox,” Yeung says. 

According to Psychology Today, a magazine looking at mental health, social media detox refers to “self-initiated periods of abstinence from social media as a response to growing concerns about the over-usage of such platforms”.

Yeung used to be a social media addict and spent around 10 hours a day to satisfy her craving. She thinks social media makes her feel inferior when comparing her life with others. 

“Especially during that exam period, I saw a lot of my friends posting photos taken in social gatherings whenever I scrolled through Instagram. I felt alone as I was always busy studying at home,” the global business student from the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology says.

“People often say do not compare with others as we are all unique but sometimes it is human nature to do so. The social comparisons are further magnified as almost everything posted online is packaged,” the 18-year-old student adds. 

After undergoing social media detox, Yeung feels healthier both physically and mentally. Instead of spending most of the time scrolling her smartphone and procrastinating on doing exercises, she now picks up old hobbies such as aerial yoga.

“I stopped being envious once I realised what people post is actually far from reality. Quitting social media temporarily was a great way to help me focus on my own life,” she says. 

“I stopped being envious once I realised what people post is actually far from reality. Quitting social media temporarily was a great way to help me focus on my own life.”

Edith Yeung Tsz-ning doing aerial yoga after social media detox
(Photo Courtesy of Edith Yeung Tsz-ning)

Similar to Yeung, university student Madeline Ho Ji-yin struggled with emotional problems due to the use of social media. She went on a 14-day social media detox when preparing for the Hong Kong Diploma of Secondary Education Examination in 2021. 

“My friends used to post photos of them studying hard. It was like the academic stress existed wherever I went and whoever I talked to. Then I decided to take a break from all social media platforms, including Whatsapp,” the communications major student from Simon Fraser University says.  

During the detox period, Ho learnt to take control of her own pace in life. She even taught herself how to play the guitar, which has since become her favourite me time activity.

The detox process was challenging for Ho as there were times when she had a strong urge to check social media. But she says it was mostly because she was curious about how her friends were doing and was afraid that her friends might find her sudden disappearance worrying.

Used to spend four hours a day on social media, Ho only spends one hour on these platforms now.

“Social media is no longer an essential part of my daily life. It has become something I only take a look at while waiting for a bus. Sometimes, I do not even bother using these apps for a couple of days,” she says. 

Madeline Ho Ji-yin playing her guitar after social media detox. She now plays the guitar once a week.  
(Photo Courtesy of Madeline Ho Ji-yin)

Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen is aware that young people like Yeung and Ho can easily fall for social media addiction.

She left the company and disclosed thousands of its internal documents to the Securities and Exchange Commission in the United States and The Wall Street Journal in September 2021. 

The former Facebook employee said the social media giant is aware of its impact on teenagers during an interview with Scary Mommy, an online parenting website, in December 2021. 

“Facebook knows that when it comes to addictive behaviour, teenagers are not as good at self-regulation as adults are… These things are like cigarettes: teenage brains are still developing, and kids say: I know these platforms make me feel bad, and I can’t stop, but if I leave, I’ll be ostracised,” Haugen said.

“These things are like cigarettes: teenage brains are still developing, and kids say: I know these platforms make me feel bad, and I can’t stop, but if I leave, I’ll be ostracised.”

“Facebook has realised that if they change the algorithm to be safer, people will spend less time on the site, they will click on less ads, they will make less money,” she said during another interview on 60 Minutes, an American television news broadcast, in October 2021.

Another former Facebook employee, Derek Chan*, thinks technology should not be held responsible for people’s addiction or the toxic comparison among people.

“Technological advancement is a must. It is common to see people’s filtered and beautified versions on Instagram rather than their true selves. Users should be aware that not everything on social media is truthful,” he says.

To tackle users’ social media addiction problem, Chan says tech companies have introduced measures that allow users to be informed about their own digital behaviour.

“Facebook and Instagram allow users to check the number of hours spent on the apps. As for Apple, people can see their screen time and set time limits for social media app usage. These features help users to be aware of their daily screen time,” he says.

Apple has introduced a “time limit” function so that users can set a time limit for individual apps like Signal on their iOS devices. Once you have reached your time limit, the iOS system will block your access to that app.

Dominic Yeo Tien-ee, an associate professor in the Department of Communication Studies at the Hong Kong Baptist University, points out that the pandemic has worsened the problem of addictive social media use.

“Social media has become a greater avenue for people to pass time when other entertainment and leisure outlets are closed during the pandemic,” he says.

Like the internet, smartphone or gaming addiction, Yeo thinks social media addiction can lead to sleeping problems and mental health disruption. He says many people thus undergo detox to combat the addiction. 

He further explains that not everyone wishes to quit their social media for good, so they prefer to engage in “disconnective practices” such as social media detox, which entails a relatively short period of disconnection from these platforms. 

But he doubts whether social media detox is the long-term solution to addiction and comparison.

“Social media detox is like a form of dieting. Like real dieting, people may rebound and gain weight that they lose,” Yeo says. 

“Social media detox is like a form of dieting. Like real dieting, people may rebound and gain weight that they lose.”

“Unless social media detox is accompanied by long term changes in use habits, or else its benefits might be very limited,” he adds.

*Name changed at interviewee’s request

Edited by Kajal Aidasani
Sub-edited by Alina Chen

Big Brother is “Protecting” You: China’s Anti-fraud App

An official anti-fraud app promoted by the Chinese government is disliked by many young Chinese.

Leopold Chen

Hongkonger Gary Kuang*, who lives in Foshan, Guangdong, was detained for two hours, as he refused to let a police officer check if he had installed the National Anti-fraud Centre App in his smartphone on August 19, 2021. 

“The officer stopped me when I was walking down a street. He asked whether I had installed the app. I said yes, but actually I did not. I just wanted to get rid of him. The officer then told me to show him my phone screen and I immediately told him he does not have the right to check my phone,” the 20-year-old student, who declines to reveal his full identity out of fear that the police may trouble his family, recalls. 

Kuang was then taken to a police station and was detained.

 “I do not want to download the app, because it can access phone users’ messages, app installation, websites visiting records and track the use of VPN,” Kuang says.

Kuang, who now studies in Beijing, says his college also requires students to download the app and send a screenshot to the class WeChat group to prove they have downloaded it.

“When asked whether I had downloaded it, I directly said no. I told the college that I would not install it and they did not trouble me further,” Kuang says.

 “I do not want to download the app, because it can access phone users’ messages, app installation, websites visiting records and track the use of VPN.”

A “Super Warship” is Watching You

The app was developed by the police and launched in early March last year. It has been promoted by the authorities nationwide in China. 

People have been told to install the app by various parties, including property management staff of their residence and their working units.

The Guangzhou Daily, owned by the Guangzhou Committee of the Chinese Communist Party, stated the app is a “super warship” against frauds.

“With the app, users can easily report frauds and evaluate risks. The app also alerts users of possible scams and exposes the latest scam cases,” the newspaper reported. 

The app requires 29 permissions from a user’s device, including reading and removing incoming messages without telling the user and editing system settings. Users must also enter their identification numbers and home addresses when registering for it. 

Information Accessed by the National Anti-Fraud App

Messages on users’ phones
Identity document number
Residential address
Facial information

Ubiquitous Promotion

The authorities have mobilised civil servants to promote the app and urge the public to download it. 

Tia Huang*, a university student union member in Shenzhen, Guangdong who declines to reveal her identity, is one of those who has been assigned to promote the app on campus. 

“We were required to start promoting the app in late March by a teacher from the Youth League Committee. We promoted anti-fraud information on the campus vaccination site. App installation was voluntary,” Huang says. 

Huang reveals that the student union organised lucky draws for those who had downloaded the app on the vaccination site as soon as they finished downloading. She says prizes such as speakers and earphones were donated by district police. 

“As far as I know, the district police ordered my university to help promote the app on campus. Then the university assigned the task to us,” she says. 

The promotion stopped in late April 2021 after some students complained about the privacy risks of using the app. 

Huang confesses that she does not know the functions of the app well and she dislikes the way the app is promoted. 

“I do not know what is special about the app except that it can identify suspicious calls and messages. It is nothing new. Other apps can also do it. Its functions are not clearly stated and cannot convince me (of its effectiveness),” she says. 

Huang says her friends, whose parents work for the police force, asked her to do them a favour by downloading the app. 

“Officers are required to ask at least five people to download the app in order to meet the quota given to them. My mom, who is a civil servant, also told me to download the app,” she says.

“I do not know what is special about the app except that it can identify suspicious calls and messages. Its functions are not clearly stated and cannot convince me (of its effectiveness).”

App As A Surveillance Tool

Tomoko Ako, a professor from the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences of the University of Tokyo, says the Chinese government is strengthening its surveillance system in the name of protecting people’s rights and safety.

“When everyone is watched by Big Brother, people cannot create and express themselves freely due to fear,” Ako says. 

Ako also points out that her colleagues are forced to install Chinese apps like Tencent Meeting to join academic activities with Chinese institutes.

“China is not a democratic country. The authorities can control everything in cyberspace,” she says. 

“Chinese apps ranging from banking apps to video streaming platforms have been found to excessively collect sensitive user data, often without user consent,” The University of Toronto’s Citizen Lab stated in a report published in January 2022. 

The report scrutinises the privacy risks and censorship problems of My2022, an app which all attendees of the Beijing Winter Olympics are required to download.

But Ako remains optimistic that people can voice opposition to the National Anti-fraud Centre App. 

“The internet industry is productive in China. I think the Chinese government will not shut down everything online. So people can still express their ideas,” Ako says. 

“I doubt the app is about countering scams. It is important for the government to explain more, such as on how the users’ data will be collected and stored,” she adds.

“I think the Chinese government will not shut down everything online. So people can still express their ideas.”

Edited by Leung Pak-hei
Sub-edited by Angel Woo